Disney Cruise Line now has two private destinations in The Bahamas: the beloved Castaway Cay and the newer Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point on Eleuthera. Which one should you be hoping for on your itinerary?
Castaway Cay: the classic
Castaway Cay has been a fan favorite for decades. The ship docks right at the island, so you can stroll off whenever you like — and pop back on board for a nap or lunch.
- Family beach with a water play area for kids
- Adults-only beach (Serenity Bay) for a quieter day
- Bike rentals, snorkeling, and a 5K run on some sailings
- Included BBQ lunch spots and beverage stations
Lookout Cay: the newcomer
Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point opened in 2024 and leans into Bahamian culture, with local art, music and food woven throughout. Its beaches are beautiful, and the whole space feels more natural and spread out.
- Bahamian-inspired design, entertainment and cuisine
- Long, gorgeous stretches of beach
- Family and adults-only areas
- Cabanas and excursions for a splurge day
Side-by-side
| Castaway Cay | Lookout Cay | |
|---|---|---|
| Vibe | Classic, polished Disney | Natural, cultural, spacious |
| Getting around | Compact, easy trams | More walking / trams from the pier |
| Best for | Little kids, first-timers | Beach lovers, repeat cruisers |
| Jordy’s pick | Honestly? Both. Hope for an itinerary that visits each! |
Tips for either island
- Get off early — the best beach chairs go first.
- Bring water shoes and reef-safe sunscreen.
- Book cabanas the moment your booking window opens; they sell out.
- Check the “all aboard” time in the Navigator app and set an alarm.
Island amenities and excursions can change between seasons. Check your sailing’s details in the Navigator app before you go.